After a bit of research I gathered a bit of information regarding the server. The Seahorse was sadly taken from us in the month of October which did cause a great deal of upset as our Seahorse was loved by people all around.
As you can see from the graph above, the month of October lead to the downfall in players on the server and is no doubt about it related to the removal of our beautiful Seahorse. I believe the answer to making the server great again is the reimplemention of our beloved Seahorse.
Thank you all for taking the time to read this post and I hope you all see the light as this is 100% the solution and you cannot disagree.
Supreme High Command Of USG